• Home
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Design
  • Posters
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About
  • Privacy Policy

Loser City

Multimedia Collective

  • Home
  • Releases
  • Features
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Interviews
  • Art
  • Submissions
You are here: Home / Features / The Fault, Dear Brutus, is Not in The Fault in Our Stars

The Fault, Dear Brutus, is Not in The Fault in Our Stars

June 6, 2014 By David Fairbanks Leave a Comment

The Fault in Our Stars poster

The title of what is likely the hit young adult romance of the decade—The Fault in Our Stars—is a riff on Shakespeare’s famous lines from Julius Caesar:

The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars,

But in ourselves, that we are underlings.

Volumes could be written about this couplet, about its implications for privilege and bootstrapping ideology. Hell, if you really wanted to, you could surely argue that The Fault in Our Stars is a criticism of the disturbingly prevalent idea that simple hard work and perseverance can allow us to overcome the limitations put upon us by our birth, whether they be class, race, gender, sexuality, or illness. The characters afflicted with cancer in John Green’s best-selling novel have accepted that their condition is no fault of their own and are capable of living a full life in spite of their shortened lifespan. If this sounds like a level of maturity you would not expect of a teenager, you would be far from the only one, but I would ask you to check your cynicism at the door.

Green’s oeuvre has a history of arguing against the common stereotypes of the American teenager, presenting protagonists and supporting cast alike as intelligent, thoughtful people who are just as human—if not more so—than the adults in their lives. The Fault in Our Stars puts him in a unique position to convince readers that a life lived in the teen years—lived only in the teen years no less—can be as full a life as one lived for decades longer. The Fault in Our Stars paints Hazel, Augustus, and Isaac as human beings filled with emotion rather than the saint-like portrayal of young cancer patients in the slightly disturbing “sick lit” genre. The novel was something I could not put down until I finished it, and I know I am not alone in saying it brought tears to my eyes. The film took the best of the novel, shucked what it needed to to keep a respectable running time, and added a little bit of flare and humor beyond the source material.

The Fault in Our Stars

The only absence I noted throughout the film was that of a particular bit of foreshadowing. It was not something necessary for the film, but it is the kind of trick that makes books work so well. Despite needing to cut reams of paper from the initial novel just to hit a 2-hour running time, Josh Boone’s adaptation serves to give the characters a different kind of depth than what was presented in the novel. We see Nick Fury and the Howling Commandos comics scattered across Augustus’s room and a V for Vendetta poster on his wall that tell us that not only are the filmmakers giving nods to the source material when they cannot directly use it, but they are staying true to and expanding on the characterization they had in the novel.

The soundtrack and relevant voice overs—from inner monologues to narration from the Diary of Anne Frank when Augustus and Hazel visit her house in Amsterdam—give scenes a very different weight than text alone could provide. Being able to hear Afasi och Filthy as Willem Dafoe sinks into a brilliantly foul portrayal of Peter Van Houten perfectly illustrated the danger of meeting your idols. The filmmakers’ technique for bringing Hazel and Gus’s texts to the screen may not seem original when such antics are on display on popular shows like Sherlock, but they gave the film another level of charm.

The Fault in Our Stars

With incredible performance all around, I have no doubt that there wasn’t a dry eye in the theater as every significant actor delivered on what was the most resounding theme of The Fault in Our Stars: the true heroes journey is not that of weakness to strength, but of strength to weakness. All of this comes as little surprise to someone who has both read The Fault in Our Stars and seen Boone’s directorial debut Stuck in Love, as the pairing of a breakout director with an incredible source material and the desire to remain faithful to the intent of the source is a recipe for success. With Boone and Wolff both attached to the upcoming Paper Towns adaptation, I expect they truly are on a roller coaster that only goes up.

Having said all of this, heaped praise upon praise on The Fault in Our Stars and genuinely believed it to be one of the best love stories I have seen in some time, I do have one significant criticism to levy at both the film and the book: they are painfully white.

The Fault in Our Stars

I struggled to find a person of color in the film outside of the very brief appearance of Hazel’s doctor. Part of this is a side effect of the American healthcare system. This is a story about people who are either living with or have survived cancer, and that’s not cheap. It takes both wealth and good insurance to survive a cancer diagnosis in the United States, and as of 2010, the percentage of African Americans and Hispanics below the poverty line was nearly triple that of caucasians. It wouldn’t be unreasonable for a handful of random cancer survivors to lean more heavily toward the caucasian, but that isn’t an excuse. This is a work of fiction. Even if Hazel weren’t on a completely fictional drug that lets her hover between life and death, there would be no excuse for the lack of diversity in the cast. As it stands, they are willing to bend the laws of science and medicine for the sake of their story—it wouldn’t have been a bad idea to have people of color play some roles, and it is here that the fault is in ourselves, for this is a thing we can control.

The Fault in Our Stars is an incredible adaptation with wonderful performances from everyone involved. It literally moved me to tears on multiple occasions. There is not a single actor I would have wanted to replace, and yet I wish it could have been as progressive in its casting as it is in its depictions of the lives and emotions of its cast.


David Fairbanks is a freelance writer, poet, and artist. You can find him on Twitter at @bairfanx.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Features, Reviews Tagged With: John Green, The Fault in Our Stars

About David Fairbanks

I write criticism, poetry, and marketing stuffs. I sometimes make art. Like my work? I'm at www.patreon.com/bairfanx

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SOCIAL

FacebookInstagramTumblrTwitter

Buy Loser City Apparel

loser city T-shirt

Be a Loser

Sign up for Loser City's mailing list to receive weekly updates about the latest articles, shows, and releases.

TRENDZ

Anatomy of a Page art Austin CBS comedy comics Dark Horse DC DC Comics documentary Fantagraphics Film Fossil Records Games HBO hip-hop horror humor IDW Image Comics Indie indie comics jake muncy manga Marvel Marvel Comics Melissa Benoist Music penny dreadful Pete Toms punk Questionable Comics Review Ryan K Lindsay sci-fi Seattle Showtime Supergirl SXSW Television the CW TV video games Video of the Week ymmv

Top Posts & Pages

  • Let's Do the Panic Again: Phantom Planet Returns

Follow Loser City

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
Instagram did not return a 200.

Follow loser_city on the Gram

Loser City is…

Comics, shows, a secret critical network -- we aim to fail big.

Danny Djeljosevic: Co-Founder

Morgan Davis: Co-Founder

Nick Hanover: Glorious Godfrey of LC

David Fairbanks: Creative Writing Editor

Kayleigh Hughes: Film Editor

Julie Muncy: Games Editor

David He: Assisting Consultant*

Contributors: Nate Abernethy, John Bender, AJ Bernardo, CJ Camba, Liam Conlon, Daniel Elkin, David A. French, Rafael Gaitan, Dylan Garsee, Stefanie Gray, Johnson Hagood, Shea Hennum, Zak Kinsella, Austin Lanari, Marissa Louise, Francesca Lyn, Chase Magnett, Justin Martin, Diana Naneva, Claire Napier, Joshua Palmer, James Pound, Mike Prezzato, Lars Russell, David Sackllah, Keith Silva, Nicholas Slayton, Carly Smith, Ray Sonne, Tom Speelman, Mark O. Stack, Dylan Tano, Mason Walker

Art

Why So Angry: Refusing to Forget Stories of Abuse

Poetry: My God, My World

Comic Cinema Club: Sorcerer by Rafael Gaitan and Mike Prezzato

Nonfiction: Progeny in Crisis by Kayleigh Hughes

The Persistence of Synergy: Scenes from the Stock Business Photo Prison Hellscape

More Art

Interviews

Dhani Harrison Plots His Own Path With Solo Debut In///Parallel

Boston Terriers and Desert Vibes: A Conversation with Jay and Sanders Fabares of “The Pale”

Questionable Comics: Becky & Frank and Rachael Stott

More Interviews

Copyright © 2021 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in