• Home
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Design
  • Posters
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About
  • Privacy Policy

Loser City

Multimedia Collective

  • Home
  • Releases
  • Features
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Interviews
  • Art
  • Submissions
You are here: Home / Features / Burn Down the Superhero Ghetto and the Graphic Novel Library

Burn Down the Superhero Ghetto and the Graphic Novel Library

May 22, 2014 By David Fairbanks Leave a Comment

There’s a pretty good chance many of you have already seen Rolling Stone‘s “50 Best Non-Superhero Graphic Novels” list. If you haven’t, I invite you to go read it before continuing on; it’s a nice profile of some of the better work in comics.

As with all such lists, even allowing them to expand to 50 titles means some beloved works will be left out; it’s the way the game works. This is not about complaining about the brilliant comics that were left off the list or some of the questionable choices that were listed among the 50 best. I’ve been a part of committees working on similar lists, and sometimes you are simply outvoted while other times you know everyone already knows they should be reading a title and feel justified in giving the spot to a comic that could use a few seconds in the spotlight.

This is about a use of language that is perpetuating a high-art/low-art dichotomy in the realm of comics. It’s about the separation of the superhero from the art form in an attempt to legitimize it and strip away the history of comic books being storytelling for children. It is rare to find a site that covers sequential art critically that also treats superhero comics with the same respect as what many would refer to as “graphic novels.”

Contract with God Will Eisner

The term is one I am not particularly fond of for numerous reasons, not the least of which is that I have heard the sneer of “this isn’t a comic, it’s a graphic novel” more times than I would like to count. It’s a term brandished to give an air of legitimacy to a medium that is already legitimate in its own right. It’s a term used by booksellers; ask any writer whether they would market their book as a short story or poem collection or a “novel in stories (or poems)” and don’t be surprised when they inform you that marketing shows that calling a book a novel boosts its sales. It’s a term used to otherize and divide a medium.

Interestingly, limiting themselves to only selecting the nebulously-defined “graphic novels” wasn’t enough for Rolling Stone; they had to segregate the superheroes from the bunch. You can’t have the cape and tights crowd popping up in your list of high-art graphic novels about a samurai rabbit or a modern retelling of Astroboy.

God forbid they get in the way of Matt Fraction and Chip Zdarsky’s hilarious and touching sex comedy or Chester Brown’s autobiographical tale of engaging in the services of sex workers (hey, can it still be called a graphic novel if it’s non-fiction?). These are graphic novels—they are for adults goddammit—and if they had to put The Dark Knight Returns on the list, it would poison their credibility as critics! Who can take their list seriously if they have a man dressed up as a bat?

Batman Dark Knight Returns Frank Miller

Segregating superheroes off to a comic book ghetto and ignoring the successful stories told in the genre is a kind of gatekeeping, as is the insistence upon referring to comic books as graphic novels. It is a closed-minded behavior that does nothing for the medium, the critics, the creators, or the fans except boost the ego of those insisting on perpetuating the high-art/low-art literary/genre dichotomy.

The stereotypes about comics and comics fans are breaking down, but it’s happening slowly. I know it can seem tempting to want to distance yourself from a stereotype you might find unappealing, and insisting that you read graphic novels instead of comics is certainly a way to push that stereotype away from you. But it’s no better than insisting that there is a measure of authenticity associated with someone’s affection for a subject, no better than perpetuating the idea of a fake fan or a fake geek girl. All it is is a childish attempt at otherizing something you find unpleasant when the fact is that it’s all just comics, whether you like it or not.

It’s all comics.
—————————————————————————————————————————————————————-
David Fairbanks is a freelance writer, poet, and artist. You can find him on Twitter at @bairfanx.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Features Tagged With: comics, graphic novels, Rolling Stone

About David Fairbanks

I write criticism, poetry, and marketing stuffs. I sometimes make art. Like my work? I'm at www.patreon.com/bairfanx

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SOCIAL

FacebookInstagramTumblrTwitter

Buy Loser City Apparel

loser city T-shirt

Be a Loser

Sign up for Loser City's mailing list to receive weekly updates about the latest articles, shows, and releases.

TRENDZ

Anatomy of a Page art Austin CBS comedy comics Dark Horse DC DC Comics documentary Fantagraphics Film Fossil Records Games HBO hip-hop horror humor IDW Image Comics Indie indie comics jake muncy manga Marvel Marvel Comics Melissa Benoist Music penny dreadful Pete Toms punk Questionable Comics Review Ryan K Lindsay sci-fi Seattle Showtime Supergirl SXSW Television the CW TV video games Video of the Week ymmv

Top Posts & Pages

  • Let's Do the Panic Again: Phantom Planet Returns

Follow Loser City

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
Instagram did not return a 200.

Follow loser_city on the Gram

Loser City is…

Comics, shows, a secret critical network -- we aim to fail big.

Danny Djeljosevic: Co-Founder

Morgan Davis: Co-Founder

Nick Hanover: Glorious Godfrey of LC

David Fairbanks: Creative Writing Editor

Kayleigh Hughes: Film Editor

Julie Muncy: Games Editor

David He: Assisting Consultant*

Contributors: Nate Abernethy, John Bender, AJ Bernardo, CJ Camba, Liam Conlon, Daniel Elkin, David A. French, Rafael Gaitan, Dylan Garsee, Stefanie Gray, Johnson Hagood, Shea Hennum, Zak Kinsella, Austin Lanari, Marissa Louise, Francesca Lyn, Chase Magnett, Justin Martin, Diana Naneva, Claire Napier, Joshua Palmer, James Pound, Mike Prezzato, Lars Russell, David Sackllah, Keith Silva, Nicholas Slayton, Carly Smith, Ray Sonne, Tom Speelman, Mark O. Stack, Dylan Tano, Mason Walker

Art

Why So Angry: Refusing to Forget Stories of Abuse

Poetry: My God, My World

Comic Cinema Club: Sorcerer by Rafael Gaitan and Mike Prezzato

Nonfiction: Progeny in Crisis by Kayleigh Hughes

The Persistence of Synergy: Scenes from the Stock Business Photo Prison Hellscape

More Art

Interviews

Dhani Harrison Plots His Own Path With Solo Debut In///Parallel

Boston Terriers and Desert Vibes: A Conversation with Jay and Sanders Fabares of “The Pale”

Questionable Comics: Becky & Frank and Rachael Stott

More Interviews

Copyright © 2022 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in