• Home
  • Releases
  • Blog
  • Design
  • Posters
  • Submission Guidelines
  • About
  • Privacy Policy

Loser City

Multimedia Collective

  • Home
  • Releases
  • Features
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Interviews
  • Art
  • Submissions
You are here: Home / Features / Respect My Authority: 20 Years In, South Park isn’t Satire, it’s the Status Quo

Respect My Authority: 20 Years In, South Park isn’t Satire, it’s the Status Quo

July 28, 2017 By Nick Hanover Leave a Comment

South Park

Few viewers who tuned in to South Park when it debuted in 1997 would have predicted the show would still be going strong twenty years later. Trey Parker and Matt Stone’s crude and belligerent cartoon has always been purposefully lo-fi and low brow, designed for immediacy and flexibility rather than staying power. And yet it not only endures but in many ways has become the establishment it railed against, now standing as one of the clearest examples of troll culture as the new status quo, its obsessive fans defending it as vital satire despite the fact that the currently dominant political movement looks and behaves exactly like the show’s cast.

While it might be unfair to lay any significant blame for the political disaster we’re living at South Park’s feet, it’s nonetheless clear that South Park no longer functions as a fuck you to the establishment but as an agent of it and any provocateur looking to shake things up today should be looking towards empathy rather than crassness. By training an entire generation to believe obnoxiously not taking a stand and mocking both sides is peak bravery, South Park has helped usher in a terrifying political landscape where caring about other people isn’t an expected responsibility in society but a revolutionary act, which in turn renders the show itself impotent, no matter how vocal its belief that it remains shocking.

Nowhere was this clearer than in Parker and Stone’s decision to “back off” of commenting on Donald Trump in the show’s 21st season, telling ABC News it was because political satire was just “more difficult” these days. This provoked Sam Barlanti at the AV Club to point out

…it’s hard not to see the “it’s too hard to make fun of real life” attitude as a predictably safe extension of the “both sides are just as bad” approach that South Park has had for years…

Where fans and defenders routinely bring up South Park’s “both sides are just as bad” mentality as proof of boldness, this has actually always been the exact quality that has kept South Park from being effective satire. The showrunners’ cowardly retreat from Trump coverage proves their goal isn’t rising to difficult challenges and fighting back against the actual establishment but lazily taking a shotgun approach to a swath of targets that are safer because of the dedicated immaturity of their base and its refusal to give a fuck about others. It goes without saying that dedicated immaturity and a refusal to give a fuck about others also happen to be the two main traits of Trump’s own base.

Matt Stone Trey Parker

tfw you become the establishment

By contrast, look at the critical and financial success of Get Out, directed by Parker and Stone’s Comedy Central peer Jordan Peele. For all the noise South Park’s creators and fans make about “PC culture” ruining everything with its callouts and lack of humor, Peele literally turned the concept of cultural appropriation into the most effective and successful horror comedy in a generation. And Peele did this at the height of Trump mania, releasing the film almost immediately after the inauguration, sending a message that was truly brave and topical without losing any humor.

Satires like Get Out don’t shy away from making pointed, aggressive statements about specific issues, and that’s part of why they will always be more necessary than anything South Park has ever attempted. And they’re even more important in times like these, when regressive conservatives are successfully turning empathy into a dirty word, childishly lashing out at any criticism of their behavior by mocking the very act of caring. This is the logical evolution of South Park’s brand of “satire,” where the only consistent target is feelings and sensitivity. Get Out is a dangerous work in the sense that it puts itself at risk by shining a light on the subtle racism that is so omnipresent in our culture, but South Park is a dangerous work in the sense that it successfully trains its fans to not give a fuck and to shout down anyone who does.

What’s promising is that the success of a work like Get Out shows that the coming generation is rebelling by actually giving a fuck and supporting works that do the same. The real brave works in culture aren’t temper tantrums about being told to not be an asshole but aggressive takedowns of the people and systems that can’t handle scrutiny. You can witness funnier, smarter satire at any given moment on Twitter than on a season of South Park, and the quickness and ferocity of the sharpest minds in these scenes serves to further highlight how sluggish and weak South Park has become. If the show was ever useful, it has long since aged out of that.

Trey Parker Matt Stone

wow such edgy so shock

This isn’t to say that South Park shouldn’t exist, or that it is entirely incapable of being effectively provocative. But on its 20th anniversary, as think pieces roll out everywhere celebrating how “sharp” it remains, it’s necessary to look back at what the show has actually accomplished and determine whether it is truly as important as its loyalists make it out to be. Can any satire that is inherently apathetic actually be considered satire? When not giving a fuck becomes the status quo, can your work still be shocking if that’s all it stands for? Or is it just lazy and useless?

It’s doubtful that Parker or Stone or their fans recognize that not giving a fuck isn’t shocking when that’s the dominant mode in politics, and South Park’s inability to grow at all and shift its aims isn’t evidence of brilliant satire but of stalling out. The duo’s sad, resigned approach to Trump should serve as a sign that by becoming one of the clearest voices of the dominant rhetoric, South Park has backed itself into a corner where it shocks no one and merely exists as one long juvenile circle jerk.

Buy Me a Coffee at ko-fi.com


Nick Hanover got his degree from Disneyland, but he’s the last of the secret agents and he’s your man. Which is to say you can find his particular style of espionage here at Loser City as well as Ovrld, where he contributes music reviews and writes a column on undiscovered Austin bands.  You can also flip through his archives at  Comics Bulletin, which he is formerly the Co-Managing Editor of, and Spectrum Culture, where he contributed literally hundreds of pieces for a few years. Or if you feel particularly adventurous, you can always witness his odd .gif battles with friends and enemies on twitter: @Nick_Hanover 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Features Tagged With: Matt Stone, South Park, Trey Parker

About Nick Hanover

Nick Hanover got his degree from Disneyland, but he’s the last of the secret agents and he’s your man. Which is to say you can find his particular style of espionage here at Loser City as well as Ovrld, where he contributes music reviews and writes a column on undiscovered Austin bands. You can also flip through his archives at Comics Bulletin, which he is formerly the Co-Managing Editor of, and Spectrum Culture, where he contributed literally hundreds of pieces for a few years. Or if you feel particularly adventurous, you can always witness his odd .gif battles with Dylan Garsee on twitter: @Nick_Hanover

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SOCIAL

FacebookInstagramTumblrTwitter

Buy Loser City Apparel

loser city T-shirt

Be a Loser

Sign up for Loser City's mailing list to receive weekly updates about the latest articles, shows, and releases.

TRENDZ

Anatomy of a Page art Austin CBS comedy comics Dark Horse DC DC Comics documentary Fantagraphics Film Fossil Records Games HBO hip-hop horror humor IDW Image Comics Indie indie comics jake muncy manga Marvel Marvel Comics Melissa Benoist Music penny dreadful Pete Toms punk Questionable Comics Review Ryan K Lindsay sci-fi Seattle Showtime Supergirl SXSW Television the CW TV video games Video of the Week ymmv

Top Posts & Pages

  • Below Her Mouth is Yet Another Disappointing Film About Lesbian Experiences
  • Miss Stevens is a Film About Loneliness That Forgets it's About Loneliness
  • Codeine Crazy
  • Visual Domination: Angelina Jolie's Sexual Power in Mr and Mrs. Smith
  • Fluid Exchange: I Roved Out by Rupert Everton
  • Fluid Exchange: Stjepan Sejic's Sunstone
  • All You See: The Fall of Family Guy
  • Bingo Love has Laudable Aims but Its Storytelling Falters
  • Unnatural Transformations: Wolf Moon is a Refreshing New Take on the Werewolf Genre
  • The Scream: Remembering Chester Bennington's Voice and Why It Connected with so Many

Follow Loser City

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
Instagram did not return a 200.

Follow loser_city on the Gram

Loser City is…

Comics, shows, a secret critical network -- we aim to fail big.

Danny Djeljosevic: Co-Founder

Morgan Davis: Co-Founder

Nick Hanover: Glorious Godfrey of LC

David Fairbanks: Creative Writing Editor

Kayleigh Hughes: Film Editor

Julie Muncy: Games Editor

David He: Assisting Consultant*

Contributors: Nate Abernethy, John Bender, AJ Bernardo, CJ Camba, Liam Conlon, Daniel Elkin, David A. French, Rafael Gaitan, Dylan Garsee, Stefanie Gray, Johnson Hagood, Shea Hennum, Zak Kinsella, Austin Lanari, Marissa Louise, Francesca Lyn, Chase Magnett, Justin Martin, Diana Naneva, Claire Napier, Joshua Palmer, James Pound, Mike Prezzato, Lars Russell, David Sackllah, Keith Silva, Nicholas Slayton, Carly Smith, Ray Sonne, Tom Speelman, Mark O. Stack, Dylan Tano, Mason Walker

Art

Why So Angry: Refusing to Forget Stories of Abuse

Poetry: My God, My World

Comic Cinema Club: Sorcerer by Rafael Gaitan and Mike Prezzato

Nonfiction: Progeny in Crisis by Kayleigh Hughes

The Persistence of Synergy: Scenes from the Stock Business Photo Prison Hellscape

More Art

Interviews

Dhani Harrison Plots His Own Path With Solo Debut In///Parallel

Boston Terriers and Desert Vibes: A Conversation with Jay and Sanders Fabares of “The Pale”

Questionable Comics: Becky & Frank and Rachael Stott

More Interviews

Copyright © 2023 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in